Methodist add warning over election treatment of asylum issue - news from ekklesia

By staff writers
April 13, 2005

Find books now:

Methodist add warning over election treatment of asylum issue


The Methodist church has added its voice to calls from other churches and Christians for politicians to stop making political capital out of the plight of asylum seekers.

The Methodist Church is calling for a sensible debate on immigration, "rather than allowing the topic to become an exercise in election point scoring."

The Church is also warning that playing up false concerns about immigration will lead to an increase in attacks on ethnic minorities - a point made recently by the Immigrant Advisory Service.

Naboth Muchopa, Methodist Secretary for Racial Justice said; "Asylum is a matter of life and death. It should not be a divisive issue nor does it have to be racialised. As we approach the General Election, politicians should refrain from using asylum as well as immigration as a political football, and from using unwarranted fears and misinformation to win votes.

"By exploiting public fears over immigration and asylum, politicians risk a surge in racially motivated violence and harassment of ethnic minorities. Political parties must behave in a responsible manner, remembering that although they may see building a campaign on myths and fears about asylum and immigration as a potential vote winner, the long term damage that may be caused to families and communities could be considerable."

Anthea Cox, Coordinating Secretary for Public Life and Social justice, added, "As the political parties fight, the real losers are the refugees and asylum seekers. We believe a sensible debate on immigration can be of great benefit to the UK as a whole. Britain has a long history of immigration, and has benefited tremendously from the energy, ideas and hard work brought to this country from overseas."

The Anglican Bishop Ripon and Leeds and Christian churches in West Yorkshire entered the general election debate on migration by urging political parties not to stoke fears about asylum seekers during the campaign.

Some 400 people attended a recent protest in Leeds over the mistreatment treatment of asylum seekers in Britain. Organiser Dave Young told the BBC that churches had serious concerns that the asylum issue was used as a "political football", re-iterating the earlier plea, reported by Ekklesia, made by churches across the UK.

The West Yorkshire Ecumenical Council (WYEC) has called for a ìradical revisionî of current asylum policy. The Council, which represents all the major Christian churches in the county, says that in its own direct experience asylum seekers are often ìdestitute, terrorised and imprisonedî.

In a public statement, the Bishop of Ripon and Leeds, John Packer, said: "The church leaders of West Yorkshire deeply regret the way in which concern for the needs of asylum-seekers seems to have been replaced by a desire to treat them harshly. All human beings are created by God and should be treated with dignity and generosity of spirit. The greater their need, the more they deserve our compassion and practical help.î

Bishop Packer continued: ìWe call on our political leaders to refrain from exploiting the plight of asylum-seekers and misleading the electorate by confusing the issues of asylum and immigration.î

Asking for a radical change of policy in favour of the persecuted and destitute who come to Britain for refuge, the Bishop added: ìIn the light of the parable of the Good Samaritan, we ask Christians to challenge their political candidates on the treatment of asylum-seekers - and to take their response into account when deciding how to vote.î

Meanwhile in London church leaders are also speaking out. United Reformed Church minister Vaughan Jones, who heads up a multi-agency project, Praxis, which works with people displaced across the capital, said today that ìthe whole experience of the Bible leads Christians to the defence of people in exile.î

Mr Jones, an Ekklesia associate, says that the debate about immigration and asylum is being confused both by politicians and the media. The churches, he declares, must stand up for the truth in the face of misinformation.

The statements of church leaders refusing the anti-immigrant and anti-asylum seeker tone of the general election debate come on a day when Conservative Party leader Michael Howard stands accused by a UN refugee agency representative in Britain of whipping up false fears.

But churches and humanitarian agencies are not just targeting the Tories. They have been critical of the Labour government too. ìThey are saying that politicians of all hues must put justice for the vulnerable above cheap political point scoring,î says Ekklesia research associate Simon Barrow.

Ekklesia, a religious think tank that has been named as one of the top 20 think tanks in the UK by The Independent newspaper, has also announced the launch of a major Westminster Forum, the first meeting of which will tackle immigration policy.

And church figures have joined politicians in expressing alarm at the actions of a Christian candidate who has had to publicly apologize after doctoring photos to support Tory immigration policy.

The full statement from the West Yorkshire church leaders was first published a week ago on Ekklesia.

Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.