Haiti reconstruction must be based on justice

By Juan Michel
January 25, 2010

As churches and church related organisations mobilise resources to bring immediate relief to the people of Port-au-Prince, they are also advocating for the international community to waive Haiti's foreign debt while building a more sustainable future for the country.

Two weeks after the country's worst earthquake in two centuries struck on 12 January 2010, the plight of the victims has prompted a worldwide mobilisation of churches' resources.

Pledges of funds, delivery of emergency aid items and appeals for donations are reported from all around the globe, while messages of solidarity, prayers and even hymns to express the sorrow flow in from near and far.

The situation of Haiti's devastated capital justifies such a level of mobilisation and much more, according to church witnesses there. "Thousands of houses are flattened", reported the president of the Protestant Federation of Haiti, the Rev Sylvain Exantus, in an email calling for international solidarity soon after the earthquake.

"Thousands of houses are flattened, as well as schools, ministries' buildings, the national government headquarters, the Justice Palace, churches, the Cathedral, the Parliament, the Ministry of Education, hospitals", said Exantus, who survived the quake but was trapped downtown and could only reach his home a day later, where he found his family alive. "It is chaos in Port-au-Prince."

The city and the surrounding urban areas are home to between 2.5 and 3 million people. At least 150,000 people were killed, a figure that could rise to 200,000.

"The disaster in Haiti has brought to the fore the heavy burden its people have been carrying over long decades because of political instability and poverty", said World Council of Churches (WCC) General Secretary, the Rev Dr Olav Fykse Tveit.

As the country's foreign debt crucially contributes to its impoverishment, the WCC and ecumenical partners are advocating for immediate and unconditional debt cancellation as a way to make certain Haiti can rebuild itself in the long term.

Facing total devastation

The damage to a city "already beleaguered with staggering poverty" is massive, said a report issued by a partner organisation of the WCC, ACT Alliance (Action of Churches Together), a global ecumenical grouping of churches and related agencies working on emergency relief and development.

"An estimated 60 to 80 per cent of buildings in Port-au-Prince were destroyed. More than one million people are without adequate shelter and no immediate prospect of accommodation in camps", added the report. To make things worse, looting and violence were reported during the first days as people competed for limited food and water supplies.

The devastation has not spared the churches. The Roman Catholic archbishop of Port-au-Prince, Joseph Serge Miot, is among the dead, as is the Rev Bienne L'Amerique, vice-president of the Protestant Federation of Haiti. Many other members of the clergy are reported dead, missing or wounded. Church buildings, facilities and schools are shattered.

"A lot of church members are now homeless. They spend the night in the streets. They are starving", reported the Rev Gedeon Eugene, vice-president of the Haitian Baptist Convention, a WCC member church, in an email two days after the earthquake. "They cannot cook, they are thirsty, they are injured", he added.

The convention sent a team of pastors to Port-au-Prince from Cap-Haïtien, a city in the Northern coast of the island, in order to bring first aid items and assess the situation. "They are visiting some survivors, brothers and sisters from our churches, encouraging those whose parents, children, husbands, wives died in the disaster, giving a hopeful word to the homeless", said Eugene.

"From the first day, people gathered to pray and sing together", said Sylvia Raulo, who is the representative in Haiti of the Lutheran World Federation's Department of World Service and was in the city during the earthquake. "There are no answers for a tragedy like this, but churches share in people's suffering and help them to express their pain, playing a role of accompaniment."

"Many people are leaving Port-au-Prince for the countryside", said the General Secretary of the Protestant Federation of Haiti, the Rev Romulus Fritz-Gérald in an online conversation. He survived the quake as did his family. His wife is a nurse who is working "20 hours per day" at the hospital.

As thousands of quake survivors become internally displaced people, they pose an additional challenge to the relief agencies, which already face huge obstacles in getting supplies into the country due to the collapse of infrastructure such as roads and bridges.

However, ACT Alliance members are providing many tonnes of food, tents, hygiene, health and baby care kits, blankets, water purifiers, and portable hospitals. The alliance is preparing to step up its work with psychosocial support and shelter and site planning, as well as water and sanitation.

As time passes and people gradually realise what has happened, they will need immense courage to face the consequences of total devastation, said Raulo. "While humanitarian aid is coming in – and huge amounts of development aid will be needed in the long term to rebuild the public infrastructure – spiritual support is equally important right now and will continue to be so in the coming months."

Grants, not loans

For the WCC General Secretary, "the time has come for the international community – politicians, business and civil society organisations – to focus on how Haiti can become sustainable". This is the message Tveit intends to bring to the meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, which he is attending this week. The forum has set aside a time to discuss the situation in Haiti.

According to Tveit, "authentic development for Haiti will take some bold steps by the international community in addition to the current emergency efforts". First among them is "the immediate and unconditional cancellation of the country's foreign debt. It would be morally untenable to do otherwise at this time of extraordinary hardship and destruction".

Despite having had 1.2 billion US dollars of debt written off last June by the international financial institutions, Haiti's debt amounts to some 640 million dollars, with annual payments of about 50 million dollars required just to service the interest on the debt.

For Tveit and the WCC, debt cancellation would be an important step in the right direction, although not a solution per se.

The international community needs to show moral leadership and make sure that "any financial assistance to rebuild the country comes as grants rather than loans", said Tveit. "And those grants cannot be tied to the detrimental conditions that international financial organisations tend to impose on poor countries", he added.

"This is not just about helping Haiti", said Tveit, "but about empowering and working with its people towards a sustainable society, one that is based on justice".

More information about the ACT Alliance response can be found here: http://www.act-intl.org


(c) Juan Michel is media relations officer for the World Council of Churches, based in Geneva. He is from from the Evangelical Church of the River Plate in Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.