Mutuals should not be 'forced through', say TUC and co-operatives

By agency reporter
August 21, 2013

Government plans to outsource public service provision to independent employee-led mutuals should be subject to a ballot of employees and not be "forced through" against their will, Co-operatives UK and the Trades Union Congress (TUC) have warned.

The two umbrella groups which represent co-operatives and unions say that ministers should not ignore the views of workers in their drive to mutualise services.

To date, around 70 public service mutuals have been formed, controlling public expenditure of over £1 billion. Whilst there have been some examples of good staff engagement, the TUC and Co-operatives UK are concerned that not enough public sector mutuals offer employees a genuine voice in the formation or running of the new business.

The civil service pension scheme manager MyCSP, for example, was formed as a private business without a ballot for staff on the transfer and operates without the genuine accountability that would make it a true mutual. Employees hold just 25 per cent of shares in a trust, with 35 per cent being held by the government and 40 per cent owned by private investor Equiniti, led by former employees of outsourcing firms Serco and Capita.

Several spin-outs of mutuals across the NHS have proceeded without full support from staff.

The TUC and Co-operatives UK have signed up to an historic joint set of best practiceguidelines setting out the conditions that should be in place to ensure public service mutuals are based on employee support and offer genuine employee ownership and representation.

The guidance calls for the government to establish quality standards in its programme of public service mutualisation and outlines a set of principles agreed between trade unions and representatives of the co-operative and mutual sector.

The guidance addresses concerns in five key areas where the two organisations have identified best practice for successful mutualisation:

- workforce engagement and consultation in the process
- governance and democracy in the mutual
commissioning of services
- safeguarding of public assets
- employment standards

TUC General Secretary Frances O'Grady said: "Increasing numbers of employees are leaving the public sector through the government's mutualisation programme, often against their will.

"The mutuals that are being formed often don't meet the democratic and open criteria of genuine co-operatives. In fact, many are simply privatised services under the cover of mutuals.

"These new entities will give controlling stakes to investors rather than workers and allow important public institutions to be taken over by large for-profit providers.

She concluded: "We hope that this guidance ensures that where public service mutuals are created, they are done so with explicit employee support and genuine ownership and representation in any new organisation."

Secretary General of Co-operatives UK Ed Mayo said: "I am a strong supporter of the mutual option for public services as a way to empower staff and engage service users. But it needs to be done well. You can't be genuinely employee owned if, in terms of culture and governance, there is no sense of employee ownership.

"There are international principles which safeguard the co-operative model, as a form of mutual. This guidance draws on these principles, and pioneering work with co-operative schools, to set out how to protect and promote the interests of employees and others who have a direct stake in the quality of our public services."

TONIGHT: * Can banking really be made ethical - http://www.ekklesia.co.uk/node/18855
* Making 'social enterprise' credible - http://www.ekklesia.co.uk/node/18853

[Ekk/4]

Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.