Education about religion in schools 'can help combat fundamentalism'

By staff writers
January 20, 2015

The Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland believes that non-proselytising religious education in the school curriculum can help promote cooperation in place of fundamentalism

The Rt Rev John Chalmers says that a rounded education in the substance and practise of religion is critical if the rise in religious fundamentalism around the world is to be challenged and defeated.

In his New Year message, Mr Chalmers said that any attempt to remove religious education from Scottish schools should be resisted.

Others have argued that it needs to move out of primarily church hands and become 'beliefs and values' style education fit for an increasingly mixed-belief society.

In his statement from December 2014, An Educational Curriculum fit for these days of Religious Intolerance, written before the Paris killings and the latest news about Boko Haram, Mr Chalmers declared: “As we enter a new year there is probably no issue of any greater concern around the world than the rise of religious fundamentalism. Nothing is more dangerous than the radicalised mind and there is nothing worse than the indoctrinated child. We will not, however, defeat such extremism simply by confronting it across battle lines. The frontline for winning this battle is education and the school is the place where young minds need to be introduced to the power of critical enquiry. How else will a young person ever grow to be able to make wise choices unless they are allowed access to the widest possible range of knowledge and how else will they learn tolerance unless they are introduced to the wide ranging menu of different ideas that populate the world.

"Peace in our time will only come when we find the means to respect those with whom we disagree and when we have matured to the point that we can discuss our deepest held views on religion, philosophy and politics without seeking to impose ours on others. Such tolerance, however, will not come by removing, as some desire, religious observance from the school curriculum; on the contrary what we should be doing is building on the strong tradition of religious reflection which is currently a part of the Scottish school environment.

"The Scottish education system is amongst the best in the world. It produces free thinking, independent and creative minds and it does so by opening up the world ideas as they are practised across the world and across every major discipline. One of the most important of these disciplines is that of properly understanding the faiths that motivate most of the world’s population. I am not advocating any measure of proselytising within our schools, but I am saying that knowledge of the substance and practise of religion must be part of any rounded education. Intolerance would, in my view, be the resultant outcome of turning Time for Reflection in schools into a choice.

"There is a theory prevalent in western society that secularism is an unstoppable bandwagon. Sociologists in the 1960s were sure that secularism and modernity went hand in hand and it was only a matter of time before religious views of the world would be passé. It is clear, however, that such theories have been proved wrong. Peter Berger, of Boston University reassessing the place of religion in society writes, “I think that what I and most other sociologists of religion wrote in the 1960s about secularisation was a mistake. Our underlying argument was that secularisation and modernity go hand in hand. It wasn’t a crazy theory. There was some evidence for it. But I think it’s basically wrong. Most of the world is certainly not secular. Religion continues to be important to people in many countries. The one exception is Western Europe. One of the most interesting questions in the sociology of religion today is not ‘How do you explain fundamentalism in Iran? but, ‘Why is Western Europe different?'"

the notion that education about religion and belief in schools can be a help in combatting fundamentalism is widely shared, but there are strong differences about how it should be taught and by whom.

Humanists are pressing for non-religious beliefs to be taught fully and adequately, and along with non-conformist Christians and others would like to see an end to compulsory worship and a fully plural Time for Reflection' alongside fair and balanced beliefs education.


Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.