More oversight needed on anti-terror legislation to protect fundamental legal rights

By agency reporter
September 22, 2018

Fundamental legal rights could be put at risk if the government proceeds with the Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill in its current form, the Law Society of England and Wales has warned.

“Everyone under suspicion of a crime should be able to access confidential legal advice, particularly when facing serious charges,” said Law Society president Christina Blacklaws.

“The idea people could be questioned for an hour before being able to get legal advice runs against all the usual standards of justice. Even after an hour, a suspect would have to proactively request a solicitor, rather than being offered legal support.The government needs to ensure everyone suspected of a crime is entitled to a solicitor and properly informed of their legal rights.”

Christina Blacklaws said the right to communicate confidentially with a lawyer would also be undermined by the bill.

“Even when a solicitor is present, the bill currently only allows the suspect to consult them when an officer is listening in”, she said. The confidential nature of communication between a lawyer and their client has long been affirmed as a fundamental human right. In our view, it is unacceptable that this principle should be undermined in such a serious case where legal advice is more important than ever.”

Christina Blacklaws also echoed Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation Max Hill QC’s calls for the government to urgently appoint his replacement.

“We recognise the importance of law enforcement agencies having the power to protect our national security, but this must be balanced with the rights of individuals. There is no point in giving up our rights to protect our rights,” she said.

“The independent advisor plays an important role in ensuring accountability. That this role might be left empty at a time when this significant piece of legislation is being rushed through is deeply concerning.”

* Details of the Bill can be found here

* The Law Society


Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.