Faith schools selecting white, middle-class pupils

By staff writers
16 Sep 2007

A new report has revealed that faith schools are turning their backs on their original remit to tackle the poor and vulnerable, and selecting proportionately more white, middle-class pupils.

Faith schools are 'cherry picking' too many children from affluent families and contributing to racial and religious segregation, according to the most extensive research of its kind, based on the government's own data, reports the Observer newspaper.

The findings drew a fierce response from the Church of England, which is seen by many, as fighting a fierce PR campaign in defence of church schools as their come under increasing criticism for discriminating in their admissions policies.

Many church schools give priority in admissions to those who attend churches attached to them - a policy which some point out is contrary to the Christian idea of prioritising those in need.

Rebecca Allen, of the Institute of Education, University of London, and Professor Anne West, Professor of Education Policy at the London School of Economics, studied the intake of faith schools across the capital using an extensive 'pupil-level' database compiled by the Department for Children, Schools and Families.

Although the majority of faith schools were established to educate the poor, the two academics said it appeared many had moved away from their original remit.

While observing there are exceptions, the researchers found religious secondary schools in London educate a smaller proportion of pupils eligible for free school meals than non-religious schools and that their intakes are 'significantly more affluent' than the neighbourhoods in which they are located.

Their research showed 17 per cent of pupils at faith schools are eligible for free school meals compared with 25 per cent at non-religious schools.

Faith schools educate just under 20 per cent of lowest-ability pupils compared with 31 per cent of non-religious schools. Faith schools also educate a greater proportion of the pupils who score highest before arriving in secondary education.

"This research poses important questions for policymakers," West said. "My concern is that the [current system] is giving schools an incentive to select pupils who are easier to teach."

Although faith schools tend to be located in less affluent inner-city areas, the research found pupils from ethnic minorities that are over-represented in such locations are largely absent. Just one per cent of Pakistani and Bangladeshi pupils are educated in faith schools, the researchers claim.

Last year research revealed many headteachers were deeply concerned about the effect of the schools on the education system. In one poll almost half felt there should be fewer or no faith schools.

Yesterday, ministers strongly denied the government was planning more faith schools. "The government has no policy to increase the number," said Ed Balls, secretary of state for Children, Schools and Families. "It is up to local communities to decide the kind of schools they want."

A spokesman for the Church of England said the research did not reflect the true picture across the country as a whole. "The LSE study focuses purely on London, which has a very different demographic to the rest of the country," the spokesman said. "The Church always has, and always will be, committed to serving the communities within which our schools are located."

The Church however stood by its admissions policies which favour church-goers before others in local communities.

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.0 England & Wales License. Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values. If you use Ekklesia's news briefings please consider making a donation to sponsor Ekklesia's work here.