A petition on the 38Degrees website is calling on the Scottish Government to cancel plans for the proposed large prison for women in Inverclyde. This plan, points out Women for Independence who are advocating on the issue, is against the recommendations of the Commission on Women in Prison, led by Eilish Angiolini, and is being pursued against expert evidence and opinion.


A petition on the 38Degrees website is calling on the Scottish Government to cancel plans for the proposed large prison for women in Inverclyde. This plan, points out Women for Independence who are advocating on the issue, is against the recommendations of the Commission on Women in Prison, led by Eilish Angiolini, and is being pursued against expert evidence and opinion.

The Scottish Government intends to put out to tender the building of a new, large women’s prison in Greenock in January 2015. Professor Andrew Coyle has described this as “….a tragedy which will be with us for decades to come.” Baroness Corston has said it will be “to the detriment of women who are going to be imprisoned there [and] an unnecessary drain on the Scottish public purse….It will fail”.

It has been estimated that 80 per cent of those in Scotland’s women’s prison at Stirling, Cornton Vale have mental health problems. Many are victims of severe physical, emotional and sexual abuse. There are high rates of self-harm and drug and alcohol problems. The majority committed relatively minor offences, and are serving short-term sentences which have little impact on reoffending. A quarter of women prisoners are on remand and only 30 per cent of them go on to get a prison sentence.

Most of these very vulnerable women should not be in prison at all, but rather in rehabilitiation supported accommodation or other rehabilitative community services.

Imprisoning women also has a major effect on their children. Around 30 per cent of their children develop physical and mental health problems, and there is a significantly higher risk of them also ending up in prison. Women prisoners who have regular contact with their children are less likely to reoffend.

In 2012, the Scottish Government set up a Commission on Women Offenders. It recommended:
* Most women prisoners on remand or serving short-term sentences should be held in local prisons.
* Supported accommodation should be commissioned as an alternative to custody
* A range of alternatives to prosecution and to imprisoning women on remand should be developed.
* Cornton Vale should be replaced with a smaller specialist prison for long-term prisoners and those who present a significant risk to the public.

The Scottish Government says it is following recommendations by building a large prison, which will house up to 350 women, in a more inaccessible location in Inverclyde. But opponents say the evidence suggests the plan is wrong and will waste resources that are needed for treatment, rehabilitation, and family support. They have until mid-January 2015 to get the Scottish Government to change its mind.

* Petition: https://you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/stop-new-women-s-prison-in-scotland-1